Hydrothermal Geothermal Energy

Extracts heat from naturally occurring underground reservoirs where hot water or steam has been heated by proximity to hot rock, converting thermal energy to electricity via steam turbines or binary cycle systems.

Earth's Internal Heat

Origin of Geothermal Energy

Geothermal energy derives from thermal energy stored within Earth's interior. This heat originates from two primary sources: primordial heat from planetary formation and ongoing radioactive decay of isotopes in the mantle and crust.

Primordial heat:

When Earth formed approximately 4.5 billion years ago, several processes generated enormous thermal energy:

  1. Accretion heating: As planetesimals and protoplanetary material collided and merged, kinetic energy converted to heat
  2. Gravitational compression: The increasing mass of the growing planet compressed interior material, raising temperatures
  3. Core differentiation: As dense iron and nickel sank to form the core, gravitational potential energy released as heat

This primordial heat has been slowly dissipating ever since, but Earth's insulating crust and mantle retain substantial residual thermal energy.

Radioactive decay:

The decay of long-lived radioactive isotopes continuously generates heat within Earth:

Isotope Half-life (billion years) Heat production
Uranium-238 (²³⁸U) 4.47 ~40% of radiogenic heat
Uranium-235 (²³⁵U) 0.70 ~4%
Thorium-232 (²³²Th) 14.0 ~40%
Potassium-40 (⁴⁰K) 1.25 ~16%

These isotopes are concentrated in the crust and mantle. As they undergo alpha and beta decay, they release energy that converts to thermal energy through particle interactions with surrounding rock.

Heat budget:

Earth's total internal heat flow to the surface is approximately 44.2 terawatts (TW), comprising:

For comparison, total human energy consumption is approximately 18 TW. Earth's internal heat flow far exceeds human energy needs, though only a small fraction is practically accessible.

Early in Earth's history, radiogenic heating was much greater because short-lived isotopes had not yet decayed. Heat production 3 billion years ago was approximately twice present-day levels, driving more vigorous mantle convection and plate tectonics.

The Geothermal Gradient

Temperature increases with depth below Earth's surface. This rate of temperature increase is called the geothermal gradient.

Average gradient:

In most continental crust, temperature rises at approximately:

dTdz2530°C/km\frac{dT}{dz} \approx 25-30°C/km

This means:

Variation by tectonic setting:

Setting Gradient (°C/km) Examples
Stable continental interior 15-25 Canadian Shield, Siberian Craton
Normal continental 25-30 Most continents
Sedimentary basins 30-40 Gulf Coast, North Sea
Active margins 40-80 Cascades, Andes
Volcanic/rift zones 80-200+ Iceland, East African Rift
Mid-ocean ridges 100-300+ Mid-Atlantic Ridge

Areas with elevated geothermal gradients are prime targets for geothermal power development. Volcanic regions, rift zones, and tectonic plate boundaries concentrate accessible high-temperature resources.

Heat flow:

Heat flows from Earth's interior to the surface via conduction and convection:

q=kdTdzq = -k\frac{dT}{dz}

Where:

Average surface heat flow:

This is roughly 0.03% of the solar energy absorbed by Earth's surface, illustrating why direct surface heat collection is impractical. Geothermal energy extraction requires accessing concentrated subsurface heat.

Temperature Profile Through Earth

Layer Depth (km) Temperature
Surface 0 ~15°C (average)
Upper crust 0-15 15-400°C
Lower crust 15-35 400-1000°C
Upper mantle 35-660 1000-1900°C
Lower mantle 660-2890 1900-3500°C
Outer core 2890-5150 3500-5000°C
Inner core 5150-6371 5000-6000°C

The lithosphere (crust and uppermost mantle, ~100 km thick) transfers heat primarily by conduction, creating steep temperature gradients. Below, the convecting mantle maintains a nearly adiabatic temperature profile with much gentler gradients (~0.3°C/km).

Hydrothermal Systems

Definition and Requirements

Hydrothermal systems are naturally occurring underground reservoirs where water or steam has been heated by proximity to hot rock. To generate electricity from a hydrothermal resource, three elements must coexist:

  1. Heat source: Hot rock (typically >150°C for electricity generation)
  2. Fluid: Water or steam to transport heat
  3. Permeability: Fractures or porous rock allowing fluid circulation

When all three elements naturally occur together, the system is called a "conventional hydrothermal resource." These represent the most economically exploitable geothermal resources.

Types of Hydrothermal Reservoirs

Vapor-dominated (dry steam) systems:

Rare but highly valuable. The reservoir contains superheated steam rather than liquid water.

Characteristics:

Examples: The Geysers (California), Larderello (Italy), Kamojang (Indonesia)

Only about 5% of known hydrothermal resources are vapor-dominated, but they produce approximately 50% of global geothermal electricity due to their superior thermodynamic properties.

Liquid-dominated (hot water) systems:

Most common type. The reservoir contains pressurized hot water.

Characteristics:

High-temperature liquid-dominated systems (>180°C) can use flash steam technology. Lower-temperature systems require binary cycle plants.

Geopressured systems:

Deep sedimentary formations containing hot water under very high pressure, often with dissolved methane.

Characteristics:

Found along Gulf Coast of USA. Not commercially developed due to technical challenges.

Reservoir Characteristics

Temperature:

Minimum temperatures for electricity generation:

Higher temperatures enable higher thermodynamic efficiency and more economical power generation.

Flow rate:

Sufficient fluid flow is essential. Production wells typically require:

Flow rate depends on reservoir permeability, well design, and drawdown management.

Depth:

Hydrothermal wells typically range from:

Drilling costs increase roughly exponentially with depth, making shallow high-temperature resources most economical.

Chemistry:

Geothermal fluids contain dissolved minerals and gases:

Component Concentration Issues
Silica (SiO₂) 100-1000 ppm Scaling in pipes, equipment
Chloride 100-100,000 ppm Corrosion
CO₂ 0.1-5% Emissions, pH effects
H₂S 0.01-2% Toxic emissions, corrosion
Arsenic 0.1-50 ppm Environmental concern
Mercury ppb levels Environmental concern

Fluid chemistry significantly affects plant design, materials selection, and environmental management.

Power Plant Technologies

Geothermal power plants convert thermal energy from subsurface reservoirs into electricity through steam turbines or binary cycle systems, using water or organic working fluids as the heat transfer medium.

Dry Steam Plants

Principle:

Steam from the reservoir flows directly through the turbine. No phase change required at surface.

Process:

  1. Production wells tap steam reservoir
  2. Steam passes through rock catcher (removes large debris)
  3. Centrifugal separator removes moisture and particulates
  4. Steam drives turbine connected to generator
  5. Exhaust steam condenses in condenser
  6. Condensate reinjected or used for cooling

Thermodynamics:

For dry steam at typical conditions (180-250°C, 5-15 bar):

Ideal Carnot efficiency:

ηCarnot=1TcTh=1313K523K40%\eta_{Carnot} = 1 - \frac{T_c}{T_h} = 1 - \frac{313K}{523K} \approx 40\%

Actual efficiency: 20-30% (accounting for irreversibilities)

Characteristics:

Major installations:

Site Location Capacity Notes
The Geysers California, USA 1,517 MW World's largest geothermal complex
Larderello Tuscany, Italy ~800 MW First geothermal power (1904)
Kamojang Java, Indonesia 200 MW Oldest in Indonesia (1975)
Matsukawa Japan 23.5 MW Only dry steam in Japan

Flash Steam Plants

Principle:

High-pressure hot water from the reservoir "flashes" to steam when pressure drops. The steam drives the turbine.

Single-flash process:

  1. Production well brings pressurized hot water to surface
  2. Water enters flash separator (lower pressure than reservoir)
  3. Portion of water vaporizes ("flashes") to steam
  4. Steam separated from remaining liquid (brine)
  5. Steam drives turbine
  6. Brine and condensed steam reinjected

Flash physics:

When pressure drops below saturation pressure, water partially vaporizes. The flash fraction depends on initial temperature and flash pressure:

xflash=h1hfhfgx_{flash} = \frac{h_1 - h_f}{h_{fg}}

Where:

For water at 250°C flashing to 1 bar: ~15-20% becomes steam.

Double-flash process:

The brine from the first flash separator enters a second, lower-pressure separator for additional steam extraction.

Benefits:

Triple-flash:

A third stage extracts even more energy. Used where very high-temperature resources justify added complexity.

Efficiency:

Configuration Efficiency Typical temperature
Single-flash 10-15% 180-250°C
Double-flash 15-20% 230-300°C
Triple-flash 18-25% >280°C

Characteristics:

Binary Cycle Plants

Principle:

Geothermal fluid heats a secondary working fluid with lower boiling point. The working fluid vaporizes and drives the turbine. Geothermal fluid never contacts turbine.

Process:

  1. Geothermal fluid (hot water) pumped from well
  2. Passes through heat exchanger
  3. Transfers heat to organic working fluid
  4. Working fluid vaporizes at lower temperature than water
  5. Vapor drives turbine connected to generator
  6. Working fluid condenses, recirculates (closed loop)
  7. Cooled geothermal fluid reinjected

Working fluids:

Fluid Boiling point Critical temp Applications
Isobutane -12°C 135°C Most common
Isopentane 28°C 187°C Higher temp resources
R-134a -26°C 101°C Low temp resources
R-245fa 15°C 154°C Medium temp
Ammonia -33°C 132°C Kalina cycle

The Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) is the standard binary configuration. The Kalina cycle uses ammonia-water mixture and can achieve slightly higher efficiency but greater complexity.

Efficiency:

Binary plants operate at lower temperatures, limiting thermodynamic efficiency:

Resource temp Binary efficiency
100°C 5-8%
120°C 8-10%
150°C 10-13%
180°C 12-15%

Characteristics:

Advantages over flash:

Combined Cycle and Hybrid Systems

Combined flash-binary:

High-temperature resources can use flash for initial power extraction, then binary cycle on the remaining brine.

Benefits:

Geothermal-solar hybrid:

Solar thermal energy supplements geothermal heat, boosting fluid temperature and power output.

Geothermal-biomass hybrid:

Biomass combustion supplements geothermal heat for higher efficiency.

Thermodynamic Analysis

Geothermal power conversion is fundamentally limited by the Carnot efficiency, which depends on the temperature difference between the hot reservoir and the cold sink. Lower geothermal temperatures compared to combustion-based plants result in lower theoretical maximum efficiencies (typically 26-45%).

Carnot Efficiency Limit

Maximum theoretical efficiency for any heat engine:

$$\eta_{Carnot} = 1 - \frac{T_c}{T_h}$$

Where temperatures are in Kelvin.

Hot side (°C) Cold side (°C) Carnot limit
150 40 26%
200 40 34%
250 40 40%
300 40 45%

Geothermal plants typically achieve 40-60% of Carnot efficiency due to:

Exergy Analysis

Exergy (available work) better characterizes geothermal resource quality than energy alone.

Specific exergy of geothermal fluid:

e=(hh0)T0(ss0)e = (h - h_0) - T_0(s - s_0)

Where:

Higher-temperature resources have higher specific exergy and greater power potential per unit mass flow.

Utilization Efficiency

Geothermal utilization efficiency compares actual power output to exergy input:

ηu=WnetEin=Wnetm˙e\eta_u = \frac{W_{net}}{E_{in}} = \frac{W_{net}}{\dot{m} \cdot e}

Typical values:

Parasitic Loads

Geothermal plants have significant auxiliary power requirements:

Component % of gross output
Production well pumps 5-15%
Injection pumps 2-5%
Cooling system 5-15%
Working fluid pumps (binary) 3-8%
Gas extraction 1-3%
Total parasitic 15-40%

Low-temperature binary plants have the highest parasitic loads (up to 40% of gross), significantly reducing net output.

Global Deployment

Installed Capacity

As of year-end 2024, global hydrothermal geothermal power capacity reached approximately 15-17 GW across 28-35 countries.

Top 10 countries (2024):

Rank Country Capacity (MW) % of national electricity
1 United States 3,937 <1%
2 Indonesia 2,653 ~5%
3 Philippines 1,984 ~12%
4 Türkiye 1,734 ~3%
5 New Zealand 1,207 ~18%
6 Kenya 985 ~45%
7 Mexico 976 ~2%
8 Italy 916 ~2%
9 Iceland 786 ~25%
10 Japan 576 <1%

Global totals:

Historical Development

Year Event
1904 First geothermal electricity at Larderello, Italy (experimental)
1911 First commercial geothermal plant, Larderello (250 kW)
1958 Wairakei, New Zealand (first large flash plant)
1960 The Geysers, USA (first US commercial plant, 11 MW)
1970s Rapid expansion during oil crises
1980 Global capacity: ~2 GW
1987 The Geysers peak: >2,000 MW
2000 Global capacity: ~8 GW
2010 Global capacity: ~11 GW
2020 Global capacity: ~14 GW
2024 Global capacity: ~16-17 GW

Growth has been modest compared to solar and wind, averaging ~3-5% annually. The geographic limitation to tectonically active regions constrains expansion.

Major Geothermal Fields

The Geysers (California, USA):

Larderello (Italy):

Cerro Prieto (Mexico):

Makiling-Banahaw (Philippines):

Salak (Indonesia):

Hellisheiði (Iceland):

Countries with High Geothermal Penetration

Country Geothermal share Notes
Kenya ~45% Rapid development, targeting 5 GW by 2030
Iceland ~25% Also >90% of heating from geothermal
El Salvador ~24% Significant renewable contribution
New Zealand ~18% Expanding capacity
Nicaragua ~15% Central American geothermal belt
Costa Rica ~12% Part of diverse renewable mix
Philippines ~12% Long history of development

These countries demonstrate geothermal's potential as a major electricity source where resources exist.

Economics

Capital Costs

Geothermal power is capital-intensive. Major cost components:

Component % of total Cost drivers
Exploration 10-15% Surveys, test wells, risk
Drilling 30-50% Depth, geology, well count
Power plant 25-35% Technology, capacity
Steam gathering 10-15% Piping, separators
Transmission 5-10% Distance to grid

Total installed costs (2020-2024):

Region/type $/kW
Global weighted average $3,500-4,500
Flash (high-temp) $2,500-4,000
Binary (moderate-temp) $3,500-5,500
Best projects $2,000-2,500
Challenging projects $5,000-7,000

Costs have not declined as dramatically as solar/wind due to:

Operating Costs

Geothermal has relatively low operating costs but requires ongoing reservoir management:

Component $/MWh
Operations & maintenance $10-20
Well workover/replacement $5-15
Make-up wells (field decline) $5-20
Royalties/land lease $2-5
Total O&M $20-50

Unlike fossil fuels, geothermal has no fuel cost, but reservoirs require active management to maintain production.

Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE)

Global average LCOE (2022-2024):

$$LCOE \approx $0.05-0.08/kWh$$

Metric Value
IRENA global weighted average (2022) $0.056/kWh
Range (project-dependent) $0.04-0.14/kWh
Geothermal hotspots (Iceland, etc.) $0.04-0.06/kWh
Moderate-temp binary $0.08-0.12/kWh

Geothermal LCOE is competitive with fossil fuels and other renewables in favorable locations, but higher than utility-scale solar/wind in most markets.

Capacity Factor

Geothermal's key economic advantage is high capacity factor:

Technology Capacity factor
Geothermal 80-95%
Nuclear 90-93%
Natural gas CC 40-60%
Coal 40-80%
Hydropower 30-50%
Wind (onshore) 25-45%
Solar PV 15-25%

High capacity factor means geothermal plants generate electricity nearly continuously, providing baseload power. This partially offsets higher capital costs.

Annual generation:

A 100 MW geothermal plant at 90% capacity factor produces: $$100 MW \times 8760 h \times 0.90 = 788,400 MWh/year$$

A 100 MW solar plant at 20% capacity factor produces: $$100 MW \times 8760 h \times 0.20 = 175,200 MWh/year$$

Geothermal produces 4.5× more energy per MW installed.

Exploration Risk

Geothermal development faces unique exploration risk:

This front-loaded risk profile deters some investors. Government risk mitigation programs (e.g., drilling insurance, exploration grants) can facilitate development.

Environmental Aspects

Emissions

CO₂ emissions:

Geothermal plants emit some CO₂ dissolved in geofluids:

Plant type g CO₂/kWh
Binary (closed loop) ~0 (operational)
Flash/dry steam (open) 15-55
High-CO₂ fields Up to 200
Global average ~45
Natural gas combined cycle ~400
Coal ~900

Binary plants with reinjection have near-zero operational emissions. Flash and dry steam plants release CO₂ from the geofluid, though far less than fossil fuels.

Some plants (Iceland, New Zealand) reinject CO₂ back into reservoirs, approaching zero emissions even for flash systems.

H₂S emissions:

Hydrogen sulfide is toxic and malodorous. Modern plants use:

Typical H₂S emissions reduced to <1 kg/MWh with abatement.

Lifecycle emissions:

Including construction, drilling, and operations:

Water Use

Geothermal water use is complex:

Open-loop systems (flash/dry steam):

Closed-loop binary:

Reservoir sustainability:

Long-term extraction can deplete reservoirs:

Reinjection of extracted fluids and supplemental water (wastewater, treated effluent) maintains reservoir pressure. The Geysers uses 20 million gallons/day of treated wastewater to sustain production.

Land Use

Geothermal has modest land footprint:

Component Land use
Power plant 1-5 hectares per 100 MW
Well pads 0.1-0.5 ha each
Steam gathering Pipelines across field
Total 10-50 ha per 100 MW

Comparable to or less than solar/wind per unit energy produced, given high capacity factor.

Induced Seismicity

Fluid injection can trigger small earthquakes:

Activity Risk level Magnitude
Production (extraction) Low Generally <2.0
Reinjection Moderate Typically <3.0
EGS stimulation Higher Up to 3-4+

Conventional hydrothermal operations rarely cause felt earthquakes. Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS), which require hydraulic stimulation, pose greater seismic risk (addressed in separate article).

Basel, Switzerland (2006): EGS project cancelled after M3.4 earthquake The Geysers: Frequent M2-3 events, rare M4+, managed through injection protocols

Monitoring and adaptive management can reduce seismic risk.

Thermal and Chemical Pollution

Thermal discharge:

Cooling water discharge can affect local water bodies. Air cooling eliminates this but reduces efficiency.

Brine disposal:

Extracted brines contain dissolved minerals (silica, heavy metals). Proper reinjection prevents surface contamination.

Scaling and corrosion:

Mineral precipitation (silite, calcite) and corrosion products must be managed to prevent equipment failure and ensure fluid does not contaminate surface environment.

Dispatchability and Grid Services

Baseload Power

Geothermal provides continuous, reliable baseload electricity:

This makes geothermal valuable for grid stability, especially as variable renewables increase.

Flexibility

Modern geothermal plants can provide limited flexibility:

While less flexible than gas turbines, geothermal can adjust output to complement variable renewables.

Ancillary Services

Geothermal plants can provide:

These grid services become more valuable as synchronous fossil generation retires.

Future Outlook

Growth Projections

Scenario 2030 capacity 2050 capacity
Current trend 20-25 GW 30-40 GW
Accelerated (with EGS) 30-40 GW 60-90 GW
High ambition (DOE GeoVision) - 60 GW (US alone)

Growth depends heavily on:

Technology Improvements

Drilling:

Target: 50% reduction in drilling costs could double economically viable resources.

Power conversion:

Exploration:

Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS)

EGS creates artificial reservoirs in hot dry rock by hydraulic stimulation. This could vastly expand geothermal potential beyond natural hydrothermal sites.

Key developments:

EGS could enable geothermal anywhere with sufficient geothermal gradient, potentially increasing global potential from ~200 GW (hydrothermal) to 2,000+ GW.

Supercritical Geothermal

Accessing supercritical fluids (>374°C, >22 MPa for water) could dramatically increase power output per well:

Technical challenges remain (materials, well control), but success could transform geothermal economics.

Summary

Key Specifications

Parameter Value
Global capacity (2024) ~16 GW
Annual generation ~95-100 TWh
Capacity factor 80-95%
LCOE $0.05-0.08/kWh
Plant efficiency 10-25%
CO₂ emissions 15-55 g/kWh
Plant lifetime 30-50 years

Technology Comparison

Type Temp (°C) Efficiency Best for
Dry steam >180 20-30% Vapor-dominated fields
Single flash >180 10-15% High-temp liquid
Double flash >230 15-20% Very high-temp liquid
Binary ORC 100-180 8-15% Moderate-temp resources

Strengths and Limitations

Strengths:

Limitations:

Role in Energy Transition

Hydrothermal geothermal energy occupies a valuable but constrained niche in the global energy system:

Current role:

Future potential:

Geothermal's unique value lies in providing carbon-free baseload power. As grids integrate more solar and wind, firm dispatchable resources become increasingly valuable. Hydrothermal geothermal, combined with emerging EGS technology, can fill this role in many regions, complementing variable renewables and contributing to deep decarbonization of electricity systems.